These Oatmeal Cream Pie Cookies are Nostalgia in a Chunk

Once I take into consideration desserts that take me again to childhood, nothing takes the cake greater than an oatmeal cream pie. There’s one thing joy-inducing about unwrapping these completely delicate cookies with candy frosting sandwiched within the center. That’s, till I truly had one just a few days in the past and realized that nostalgia doesn’t all the time stay as much as the hype. In an effort to recapture the glory of considered one of my favourite childhood cookies, I made a decision it was time to recreate the recipe for myself and make them truly pretty much as good as I remembered.

My model of the traditional oatmeal cream pie does just a few issues otherwise than the traditional. First, we’re going more healthy by lowering the sugar and including extra healthful elements. These cookies really feel like a love youngster between an oatmeal cream pie and a whoopie pie. I like them for his or her thick texture and barely savory taste balanced by the sweetness of the cream and preserves. Leaning into the flavors of summer time, we use strawberries within the filling—this completely balances a sweeter frosting with some additional tang that retains you coming again for extra.

For those who’re like me and planning on many al fresco gatherings this summer time, then this cookie will for certain be becoming a member of your picnic basket repertoire all season lengthy.

Components for These Strawberry Oatmeal Cream Pie Cookies

Coconut sugar. I like to make use of coconut sugar in these cookies for its barely extra caramely taste than brown sugar.

Lemon zest. So as to add a little bit additional taste to our cookies.

Eggs. Simply two cookies for this recipe.

Tahini. I truly love a cookie that’s not too candy, and the tahini provides a pleasant nuttiness and savory taste that retains the cookie from being too candy.

Olive oil. Use the great things.

Vanilla. I like to make use of powdered vanilla, however you too can use extract.

Rolled oats. Each entire after which blitzed for DIY oat flour.

Baking soda. To assist our cookies rise.

Butter. One stick for the frosting is all we’ll want.

Powdered Sugar. For sweetening our frosting.

Orange and lemon zest. I just like the zest for chopping by means of the richness of the frosting.

Heavy cream or milk. The key for the most effective whipped buttercream is all the time a splash of heavy cream. When whipping up the frosting, it actually helps add quantity and softness.

Strawberry preserves. Storebought is greater than excellent right here. I like Bon Mamman strawberry preserves.

Suggestions for Making ready These Cookies

With regards to cookie recipes, this one seems to be fairly fanciful, however is extremely simple to make. It’s all in regards to the little issues that actually elevate these cookies and be certain that the flavour and texture is prime notch.

First, any time I’m utilizing citrus in a dessert, I be certain to include the zest from the citrus into the sugar first. By rubbing the zest into the sugar till the feel looks like moist sand, you assist launch a few of the pure oils from the zest and maximize the flavour. I do the identical for the frosting as nicely!

For the sandwich filling, I wish to create a spherical of frosting across the fringe of the cookie after which add a spoon of jam into the center. I choose this as a substitute of solely frosting because the tangy chew from a very good high quality jam can lower by means of the sweetness.

Additionally, don’t skimp on the salt. I’m an enormous fan of the “not too candy” dessert vibe, and a giant a part of that’s making certain that there’s a pinch of salt in each element of the cookie. Belief me, it makes an enormous distinction within the taste to make sure correct salting, even in desserts.

How you can Put together These Cookies Forward of Time and Retailer Leftovers

These cookies are excellent make forward treats. Particularly since there may be some meeting required, you can also make the parts individually forward of time. Make the frosting and retailer in an hermetic container within the fridge a day or two forward. Simply let the frosting come nearer to room temperature if you’re able to assemble. You too can make the cookies a day or two forward earlier than sandwiching along with frosting.

To retailer cookies, as a result of the frosting softens at room temperature, I wish to hold these within the fridge. When able to eat, simply allow them to sit out at room temperature for a couple of minutes, then get pleasure from!

Print